Reviewer Review Report Reviewer : Topic PHYSICS OF SEMICONDUCTOR DEVICES FLOWS AND HEAT TRANSFERS RENEWABLE ENERGIES ENVIRONMENT اﻟﻔﻴﺰﻳﺎء اﻟﻄﺒﻴﺔ (Medical Physics) Title Overall Evaluation Originality/Novelty High Average Low No Answer Quality of Presentation High Average Low No Answer Scientific Soundness High Average Low No Answer Interest to the Readers High Average Low No Answer Overall Merit High Average Low No Answer English Level High Average Low No Answer Overall Recommendation Accept in present form (the paper is accepted without any further changes) Accept after minor revision (the paper is in principle accepted after revision based on the reviewer’s comments) Reconsider after major revision (the acceptance of the manuscript would depend on the revisions) Reject (the article has serious flaws and makes no original contribution, and the paper is rejected with no offer of resubmission to the journal) Comments and Suggestions for Authors If revisions are required, do you wish to review the revised version? I don't need to see the revised version I would like to see the revised version Manuscript Ethics Evaluation Do you have any potential conflict of interest with regard to this paper? Yes No Did you detect plagiarism? Yes No Do you have any other ethical concerns about this study? Yes No Comments and Suggestions for Editors Generat a pdf file Report Send